Now that we're a little over halfway through season 12 of American Idol it's safe to say we have a pretty good feel for the new judges. conducted a poll to determine the best "American Idol Judge Of All Time" Coming in first was KEITH URBAN, which is no surprise because he's AWESOME!  SIMON COWELL was second, and KARA DIOGUARDI was last.

We thought we'd try our own poll Vote below for your favorite AI judge: 

Poll: Best American Idol Judge Of All Time?